Science University Research Symposium (SURS)
Right, Wrong or Somewhere in Between? impact of Reflection on Morally Ambiguous Scenarios
Publication Date
Winter 11-23-2026
College
College of Sciences & Mathematics
Department
Psychological Sciences and Neurosciences, Department of
SURS Faculty Advisor
Adam Smiley
Presentation Type
Metadata Only
Abstract
This experimental study aimed to investigate the effect different types of reflection have on participants’ confidence in a morally ambiguous scenario. While evidence suggests that considering reasons for moral decisions can influence and change how individuals make moral judgements (Ng et al., 2023), research has yet to explore the differences that reflecting on an individual’s choice versus reflecting on the alternative choice has on their confidence when presented with morally ambiguous decisions. Ninety-six psychology students (Mage = 19.05 SD= 1.26) were randomly assigned one of two reflection conditions and were presented with four morally ambiguous scenarios. We hypothesized that participants would show a significant change in their confidence after their reflection in both conditions and that participants who reflected in the alternative answer would show a greater change in their confidence. Additionally, we hypothesized that participants who reflected in their own answer would show an increase in their confidence following their reflection, while participants who reflected in the alternative answer would show a decrease in their confidence after their reflection. Results showed that participants differed in the direction of their change after their reflection depending on the condition they were assigned to, and participants in the “own answer” condition significantly increased their confidence post-reflection; the other hypotheses did not show significant results. Our study shows that the type of reflection affects the confidence participants show in a morally ambiguous scenario; however, multiple limitations throughout the experiment do not allow us to overgeneralize these findings.
Recommended Citation
Salgado garcia, Carlota; Tanriverdi, Zara; and Roy, Kierstin, "Right, Wrong or Somewhere in Between? impact of Reflection on Morally Ambiguous Scenarios" (2026). Science University Research Symposium (SURS). 386.
https://repository.belmont.edu/surs/386
