Science University Research Symposium (SURS)

The Role of Message Valence and Presentation Format in Cognitive and Affective Empathy

Publication Date

2026

College

College of Sciences & Mathematics

Department

Psychological Science, Department of

SURS Faculty Advisor

Patrick Morse

Presentation Type

Oral Presentation

Abstract

This article examines the effects of media valence and modality on affective and cognitive empathy in viewers. Valence refers to how positive or negative the media is, while modality refers to how the media is consumed (i.e., video/written). For this study, we will be measuring affective empathy, the ability to share or experience the emotional state of another person, and cognitive empathy, the ability to intellectually understand and recognize another person's thoughts, mental states, and perspective (Reniers et. al., 2011). Andreychik and Miggliaccio (2015), along with much of the literature, they measure positive/negative emotional effects, but do not describe the specific relationship between positive/negative dimensions and cognitive/affective empathy. This study can be used to understand how media consumption can influence behaviors, emotions, and voting tendencies (Solloway et al., 2011). Participants in this study will be pulled from undergraduate students at Belmont University. Participants will be randomly split into 4 groups, each with either positive or negative valence, and written or video media. Each participant will read or watch news clips, then fill out a State Empathy Scale to measure both cognitive and affective empathy reactions to the media, as well as their general empathy. We hypothesize that visual and negative content will elicit greater affective empathy, whereas written and positive content will elicit greater cognitive empathy. Specifically, affective empathetic responses are expected to be higher among participants exposed to negative content and visual media, while cognitive empathetic responses are expected to be higher among participants exposed to positive content and written media. This study will help better understand media’s effects on empathetic responses in viewers, which can lead to a better understanding of how to impact audiences. This study can also allow audiences to better understand how certain media modalities and valences can affect them as well.

This document is currently not available here.

Share

COinS