Science University Research Symposium (SURS)

Deciding What Matters: Individual Differences in Moral Dilemmas

Publication Date

2026

College

College of Sciences & Mathematics

Department

Psychological Science, Department of

SURS Faculty Advisor

Dr. Adam Smiley

Presentation Type

Metadata Only

Abstract

Religion can significantly influence how individuals’ moral beliefs and decision-making are shaped. People’s perception and judgment of others can vary based on their religious affiliations and may impact how they decide to resolve moral dilemmas. The present study examined whether embedding religious identity cues within hypothetical moral dilemmas influences participants' willingness to help compared to scenarios excluding religious cues, and if this effect depends on the participant’s own religious affiliation. A sample of 117 undergraduate psychology students from Belmont University was recruited through the SONA system. Using a between-subjects design, participants were randomly assigned to one of two conditions to evaluate twelve hypothetical moral scenarios that either included or omitted explicit details regarding the question subject’s religious affiliation. Participants indicated their willingness to help using a four-point agreement scale and later completed a demographic questionnaire which included questions assessing participant religiosity. To quantify our research, we conducted a 2 x 2 factorial ANOVA, which revealed no significant main effect of religious cues on willingness to help. Further, it also showed no significant interaction between participant religiosity and scenario religious cues. These findings suggest that explicit religious cues alone may not be enough to alter moral judgment and willingness to help. Instead, moral decision-making appears to be highly nuanced and complex. To address the limitations of sample homogeneity and methodology, future research should recruit more diverse samples, examine real-world behaviors, and explore different moral dilemma questions.

This document is currently not available here.

Share

COinS